medically-reviewed-iconMedically Reviewed

Caregiving

The ‘Sister Sketch’ Every Daughter Felt In Her Bones - 5 Women Open Up

Nov 20, 2026

•

5 min read

Written by Preeti Prajapati•

Medically reviewed by

Dr B. S. Mahesh

Share Article

Share article icon for viewing share options

“I don’t have to worry about Dad getting the care and attention he needs, because my sister will do it.”

If that line sounds familiar, the SNL sister skit has probably landed on your feed too. It did more than make me laugh. It made me angry. It made me question: Am I the fool here? Does my brother even care, or am I being taken for granted?

As a middle sister with an older brother, I found it painfully relatable. Listen to the opening lines of the sister skit: the brother does care. He asks about Dad’s medicines and notices him slowing down. That’s what most brothers do. They care, in their head. But the practical care, the everyday time and attention an ageing parent needs, is what the sister gets called in for. After all, “he has a career and bigger responsibilities.” So who gives those minutes? The sister.

The clip racked up millions of views within days, with sisters everywhere recognising themselves in it. When I spoke to women and looked back at my own experience, the same story kept coming up, one I’d believed too: in many Indian families, the brother checks in and asks for updates, the sister handles the practical side, and so both are doing their part. But the split is closer to 10:90, and that’s what John Mulaney’s SNL sister sketch points out so well.

Always the one who comes running

When Dad was admitted, I was working out how to help before anyone asked. I got there first, checking on Dad while my sister cooked meals and managed the meds. My brother arrived the day Dad was discharged. ‘He was busy with work,’ as we always tell ourselves (and I believe it even as I write this today).

A friend later asked why I’d rushed. “Your brother would have gone on his own. Your worry is self-imposed.”

That’s the whole point. In the moment, it never mattered. They’re my parents. But it was so deeply ingrained that I never noticed it becoming my responsibility. That’s why the line in the sketch is “I have a sister”, not “I’ll call my sister”. She’s been conditioned to drop everything and come running.

It turns out I’m not the only one. Many women my age, some who belong to the sandwich generation, juggle careers, homes and ageing parents, often all at once.

Nobody asked. Nobody had to.

For Ishani Chatterji, who’s the eldest daughter, the expectations are louder, because her younger brother lives abroad.

“When my father was hospitalised last year, I managed everything, from staying overnight to looking after him while he recovered from surgery.”

Nobody sat them down to talk about it, and nobody asked her to take it on. “I probably would have stepped up anyway. But there’s a difference between choosing responsibility and having it quietly become yours by default.”

Relatives told her, “You’re the older one, you’re here.” Her parents said, “You have to be strong.” But the caregiver burden wasn’t only physical. The guilt came from inside. “I’d feel guilty for wanting to sleep in my own bed, or step out for a coffee. What if something happened while I was away?”

Youngest, but still on care duty

For anyone thinking, “Well, Ishani is the eldest daughter, so of course it’s her responsibility,” meet the youngest sister. Madhavi Dhobale, the youngest of three, became the family’s default caregiver in her 20s while her elder siblings were away studying.

“They would call and ask how Dad was, but the daily work was mine: cooking, giving him his medicines, sitting with him when he was unwell.”

In her twenties, while her friends were planning their futures, she was thinking about what Dad would eat. “I lost sleep and missed chances in my career. Nobody saw that part.” Even with a maid at home, she cooked for him herself. “His food should come from my hands. And ‘log kya kahenge’ was at the back of my mind.”

Still, she never saw it as a burden. Now in her 40s, Madhavi’s dad lives with her brother, and her sister-in-law has become his primary caregiver. Yet there are still things her dad calls only Madhavi for. “It was my way of showing love, and those years brought us very close.”

Because I’m the daughter. There, I said it.

Alisha Kalidhar doesn’t soften it. “It lands on me because I’m the daughter. Nobody announced it, but nobody expected my brother to do it either, and that’s not an accident.”

Three years in, she’s the only one with the full picture. Her younger brother isn’t adding to the load, but he isn’t sharing it either. “It was never even on the table for him to say no to. Same with our cats. He’s never once taken one to the vet.”

She’s close to her dad, so she doesn’t resent it. “But being close explains why I don’t mind. It doesn’t explain why it landed on me.” The cost? “It was taking away my ability to live my own life.”

Caring for the parents, and the care the brother cares for

For Aditi Yajnik, the part nobody counts is the emotional caregiving. “Taking care isn’t only making sure a diabetic parent has no sugar. It’s how they’re doing emotionally, and the time it takes to process all of it.”

Her brother has recently started tracking their parents’ meals from abroad. “Zooming into food photos to check if there were enough cucumbers for fibre is a lot. I know the intention is to share the load, but it’s tiring for all of us.”

As an unmarried daughter living at home, it simply became hers. “We’re conditioned to think we HAVE to do it. If not me, then who?”

Dear brother, we’re in this together

Every sister who has ever thought, “If not me, then who?”, me included, has to wonder: is it really just “I’m close to my dad”, which most of us feel? Or is it a quiet conditioning that puts it all on the women, so the men can, as the skit says, “get back to their life and the stuff they like to do”? I have a lot of questions, and I think it’s time we started asking our brothers.

Madhavi chose the role and treasures it. Alisha names the gender expectation outright. Aditi carries the emotional weight that no checklist captures. And Ishani wants her brother to see what doesn’t show: “Being able to do something doesn’t mean it isn’t difficult. I cannot be the only one living with the reality of our parents getting older.”

None of them wants to care less. They just don’t want to carry it alone. Caregiver burnout builds quietly when one person holds everything. Sometimes the answer is splitting the work. More often, as Alisha puts it, it means “having someone to check with”. If the SNL sister care joke stung a little, take it as a nudge. Talk before the next crisis, take on a task without being asked, and ask “How are you managing?”

So the next time someone says, “Well, I have a sister”, maybe the better answer is, “Well, we have each other.”

Click here for medical advice disclaimer

Share Article

Share article icon for viewing share options
Go To Articles